It's official. The Super Bowl will be played in an outdoor, cold weather venue for the first time when the 2014 game will be played at the new Meadowlands Stadium. The debate has been raging as to should the game be played in the elements, and how those elements will effect the outcome. The weather debate has been mostly about the temperature and the possiblilty of snow. But the main factor, I believe, will be the wind.
Giants Stadium is well known for its swirling winds. When the trash starts blowing around it looks like a tornado has hit inside the stadium. There hasn't been a game played in the new Meadowlands Stadium, so the wind factor and how it will blow inside has yet to be determined. Think about this: If a cold front moves through, you are going to have winds up to 20-30 mph, and you are going to have conditions similar to the Freezer Bowl game in Cincinnati back in January 1982. I watched that game on TV, and it was so cold the wind wasn't the only determining factor.
Now there is a chance that it will be warm that time of year in New Jersey. And if it is the wind will be blowing as well. Upwards of 30-40 mph. The NFL has become a quarterback driven league, and they are putting their most marketable superstars in a situation where they will not be able to perform their best.
When it comes to the Meadowlands stadium, there is a question that only a few have asked. Why didn't they put a roof on the place? I don't see the NCAA wanting to host the BCS Championship game or the NCAA Mens Basketball Championship there, but they probably would if the stadium had a roof. After all, if you are going to spend $1.7 billion on a new stadium, why not add another $100 or $200 million for a roof.
Thursday, May 27, 2010
Monday, May 17, 2010
Paying the Players
This is the time of year in the NFL when the best players feel they are underpaid and want more money. They show it by not attending voluntary OTA's, and let it be known through their agents they are unhappy with their contracts. Two of the best players in the game, Andre Johnson of the Houston Texans and Chris Johnson of the Tennessee Titans, want to renegotiate. One has a very good case, the other has a good point but won't get much sympathy.
Chris Johnson rushed for over 2000 yards in 2009, and with inconsistent play at the quarterback position he was their offense. He is also playing out a rookie contract that will pay him $550,000 in 2010. Tennessee is getting a wonderful return on their investment. Johnson is a gamebreaking back who can beat you running the ball and catching it out of the backfield. He has been arguing for more money for a while now and he should get it.
But Tennessee can point to Terrell Davis and Jamal Anderson as to why they should hold off with the new contract. Davis and Anderson lead their teams to the Super Bowl at the end of the 1998 season, then both players got hurt with serious knee injuries in the opening weekend of the 1999 season and never fully recovered. Running backs have a shorter and shorter shelf life in the NFL. Tennessee can argue that handing out a huge signing bonus to Johnson when he has the potential to get hurt the same way is pointless when he still has at least 2 years left on his contract. But when you are not willing to pay your best player it smacks of cheap. Tennessee needs to pony up and pay their thoroughbred back before it's too late.
Andre Johnson has already signed a big extension. 8 years, $60 million, with $15 million in guaranteed money. He has five years left on his contract. Johnson has been one of the best receivers in the league and with the development of Matt Schaub he is only getting better. But how much more money is he worth? He has never played in a playoff game, and only been on one team that has had a winning record. He got the big contract after putting up big numbers. What he needs to do now is get his team in the playoffs. Then he will have more leverage. Chris Johnson led the Titans to the best record in the NFL his rookie season. Andre Johnson has yet to have that effect in Houston.
Looking at their current contracts, Chris Johnson is underpaid. Andre Johnson is undeserving. Chris needs a new contract. Andre needs to put up or shut up.
Chris Johnson rushed for over 2000 yards in 2009, and with inconsistent play at the quarterback position he was their offense. He is also playing out a rookie contract that will pay him $550,000 in 2010. Tennessee is getting a wonderful return on their investment. Johnson is a gamebreaking back who can beat you running the ball and catching it out of the backfield. He has been arguing for more money for a while now and he should get it.
But Tennessee can point to Terrell Davis and Jamal Anderson as to why they should hold off with the new contract. Davis and Anderson lead their teams to the Super Bowl at the end of the 1998 season, then both players got hurt with serious knee injuries in the opening weekend of the 1999 season and never fully recovered. Running backs have a shorter and shorter shelf life in the NFL. Tennessee can argue that handing out a huge signing bonus to Johnson when he has the potential to get hurt the same way is pointless when he still has at least 2 years left on his contract. But when you are not willing to pay your best player it smacks of cheap. Tennessee needs to pony up and pay their thoroughbred back before it's too late.
Andre Johnson has already signed a big extension. 8 years, $60 million, with $15 million in guaranteed money. He has five years left on his contract. Johnson has been one of the best receivers in the league and with the development of Matt Schaub he is only getting better. But how much more money is he worth? He has never played in a playoff game, and only been on one team that has had a winning record. He got the big contract after putting up big numbers. What he needs to do now is get his team in the playoffs. Then he will have more leverage. Chris Johnson led the Titans to the best record in the NFL his rookie season. Andre Johnson has yet to have that effect in Houston.
Looking at their current contracts, Chris Johnson is underpaid. Andre Johnson is undeserving. Chris needs a new contract. Andre needs to put up or shut up.
Saturday, May 15, 2010
Reclamation and Redemption in Cincinnati
For years the Cincinnati Bengals were the team of the troublemakers. Chris Henry, Odell Thurman, and others kept getting in trouble with the law and the big sheriff of the league, Commissioner Roger Goddell. Now they seem to be the scrapheap, where the junkyard dogs that everyone else abandoned can find a home.
You can go back to 2008 and find a starting point. Chris Henry was arrested for the 5th time, and the Bengals released him. He was suspended for 8 games but there were no takers. Then Mike Brown, against the wishes of his coach, Marvin Lewis, re-signed the troubled receiver. In doing so Brown said that he is a redeemer, and that he would give Henry one last shot.
The risk seemed to be working out for the best. Henry had difficulty getting back into the flow of the game in 2008, but some of that was seen as Carson Palmer not being on the field. In 2009 Henry showed flashes of his potential before breaking his arm, then tragically died in an accident during the season. Henry had kept himself out of trouble and looked to be on the path to redemption.
When Chris Perry showed that he was not going to be a bell cow ball carrier, the Bengals took in Cedric Benson, who had been a bust with Chicago, found his own trouble with the law and was released by the Bears. When he got a second chance to show that he was deserving of his 4th overall draft selection in 2005 he took the most of it. Benson finished the 2008 season with three 100 yard games, and rushed for over 1200 yards in 2009 despite sitting out 3 games with injuries.
Going into the 2010 season the Bengals have signed Matt Jones and Adam Jones. Matt was released by Jacksonville after being arrested for drug possession, and I don't know if this blog has enough space to list the problems Adam has had since coming into the league in 2005. Both were signed to low risk contracts and will be joining a team coming off of an AFC North Division title. With the efforts the Bengals have put into Henry and Benson, they know how to handle players who have had troubles and are coming off the scrapheap. If they can stay out of trouble as Henry did and can contribute on the field the Bengals will reap the benefits.
But now there is a possibility that the Bengals might sign JaMarcus Russell. Is there a better place for him? I don't think so. With Palmer as the starter, Russell would be strictly a backup. No pressure to carry the franchise, and I'm sure if he signs with any team the financial risk will be very small. Why not take a chance on Russell? If it is going to work out, it will probably happen in Cincinnati.
You can go back to 2008 and find a starting point. Chris Henry was arrested for the 5th time, and the Bengals released him. He was suspended for 8 games but there were no takers. Then Mike Brown, against the wishes of his coach, Marvin Lewis, re-signed the troubled receiver. In doing so Brown said that he is a redeemer, and that he would give Henry one last shot.
The risk seemed to be working out for the best. Henry had difficulty getting back into the flow of the game in 2008, but some of that was seen as Carson Palmer not being on the field. In 2009 Henry showed flashes of his potential before breaking his arm, then tragically died in an accident during the season. Henry had kept himself out of trouble and looked to be on the path to redemption.
When Chris Perry showed that he was not going to be a bell cow ball carrier, the Bengals took in Cedric Benson, who had been a bust with Chicago, found his own trouble with the law and was released by the Bears. When he got a second chance to show that he was deserving of his 4th overall draft selection in 2005 he took the most of it. Benson finished the 2008 season with three 100 yard games, and rushed for over 1200 yards in 2009 despite sitting out 3 games with injuries.
Going into the 2010 season the Bengals have signed Matt Jones and Adam Jones. Matt was released by Jacksonville after being arrested for drug possession, and I don't know if this blog has enough space to list the problems Adam has had since coming into the league in 2005. Both were signed to low risk contracts and will be joining a team coming off of an AFC North Division title. With the efforts the Bengals have put into Henry and Benson, they know how to handle players who have had troubles and are coming off the scrapheap. If they can stay out of trouble as Henry did and can contribute on the field the Bengals will reap the benefits.
But now there is a possibility that the Bengals might sign JaMarcus Russell. Is there a better place for him? I don't think so. With Palmer as the starter, Russell would be strictly a backup. No pressure to carry the franchise, and I'm sure if he signs with any team the financial risk will be very small. Why not take a chance on Russell? If it is going to work out, it will probably happen in Cincinnati.
Friday, May 14, 2010
Preseason Power Rankings
Going into the 2010 NFL season, the top two teams are the New Orleans Saints and the Indianapolis Colts. The teams that faced each other in the Super Bowl look to be the strongest in their respective conferences, as neither took a major hit in personnel losses, and drafted very well to supplement the talent on the roster. The question is 'Who should be ranked #3?'
For my money, the third best team in the NFL going into the 2010 season is the New York Jets. Mark Sanchez is going into his second season, and he looks to only get better. But the focus of the offense is still the running game and the offensive line. But Shonn Greene will be looked to carry the majority of the load, and the loss of Alan Faneca might be overlooked since the rest of the offensive line has been so good. Santonio Holmes will give Sanchez another target, but he will be sitting out a 4 game suspension at the beginning of the season.
The offense will be looked to not lose games. The strength of the team is on defense. The addition of Jason Taylor and Antonio Cromartie makes the pass rush and secondary that much better. Darrelle Revis has become the best cornerback in the game. And the selection of Kyle Wilson gives them the nickel corner they lacked against the Colts in the AFC Championship game.
One thing the Jets have going for them, perhaps more than anyone else, is bravado. With Rex Ryan as the head coach, they just believe they can win. They went into Cincinnati and won a playoff game that was a toss up. They went to San Diego and won a game they had no business winning. They went to Indianapolis and nearly won the AFC title. Ryan has them believing they are the best team in football. It will be seen whether that translates to wins on the field. The Jets have an even bigger target on their backs, and the rest of the league will be taking aim.
For my money, the third best team in the NFL going into the 2010 season is the New York Jets. Mark Sanchez is going into his second season, and he looks to only get better. But the focus of the offense is still the running game and the offensive line. But Shonn Greene will be looked to carry the majority of the load, and the loss of Alan Faneca might be overlooked since the rest of the offensive line has been so good. Santonio Holmes will give Sanchez another target, but he will be sitting out a 4 game suspension at the beginning of the season.
The offense will be looked to not lose games. The strength of the team is on defense. The addition of Jason Taylor and Antonio Cromartie makes the pass rush and secondary that much better. Darrelle Revis has become the best cornerback in the game. And the selection of Kyle Wilson gives them the nickel corner they lacked against the Colts in the AFC Championship game.
One thing the Jets have going for them, perhaps more than anyone else, is bravado. With Rex Ryan as the head coach, they just believe they can win. They went into Cincinnati and won a playoff game that was a toss up. They went to San Diego and won a game they had no business winning. They went to Indianapolis and nearly won the AFC title. Ryan has them believing they are the best team in football. It will be seen whether that translates to wins on the field. The Jets have an even bigger target on their backs, and the rest of the league will be taking aim.
Thursday, May 13, 2010
Slow News Day
The NFL is a year round enterprise nowadays. But even the behemoth that the league has become can have a slow news day. Which is what I see today. Nothing to report that hasn't already been reported. But I'm sure something will pop up soon enough. It always does. Have a nice slow news day!!!
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
A Super Bowl in Jersey
The New York Giants and the New York Jets have submitted their combined bid to host the 2014 Super Bowl in the new Meadowlands Stadium. If it gets the approval from the league it would be the first outdoor, cold weather Super Bowl. The big game has been played in domes hosted by Detroit and Minnesota, and it will be in Indianapolis in 2012. But those games were played indoors. I'm hoping the game is played in Jersey.
Think about it. The possibility of snow, sleet, cold rain, wind, all of the above. Bring the elements into play. But what it will do is keep the fair weather fans from even thinking of going. Literally. It will be a game for the real fans. The ones who have watched the Packers at Lambeau Field in the Ice Bowl when it was -15F and in Favre's Last Stand in the NFC Championship in January 2008, when it was -4F. It will be for the fans who watched the Freezer Bowl in Cincinnati in the AFC Championship in January 1982, when the wind chill was -59F. It will be for the fans who were at the Tuck Rule Game in New England in January 2002, when snow blanketed the field.
But the one reason why I'm rooting for an outdoor Super Bowl in the New York Metropolitan Area is that very cold weather will hopefully cancel the stupid halftime show that for me just ruins the Super Bowl. I want to watch the two best teams in football, not some aged, over the hill rock band that probably doesn't know the difference between a Cover 2 and two covers on a bed. Let's get back to real football. And in January and February that means Real Cold Football.
Think about it. The possibility of snow, sleet, cold rain, wind, all of the above. Bring the elements into play. But what it will do is keep the fair weather fans from even thinking of going. Literally. It will be a game for the real fans. The ones who have watched the Packers at Lambeau Field in the Ice Bowl when it was -15F and in Favre's Last Stand in the NFC Championship in January 2008, when it was -4F. It will be for the fans who watched the Freezer Bowl in Cincinnati in the AFC Championship in January 1982, when the wind chill was -59F. It will be for the fans who were at the Tuck Rule Game in New England in January 2002, when snow blanketed the field.
But the one reason why I'm rooting for an outdoor Super Bowl in the New York Metropolitan Area is that very cold weather will hopefully cancel the stupid halftime show that for me just ruins the Super Bowl. I want to watch the two best teams in football, not some aged, over the hill rock band that probably doesn't know the difference between a Cover 2 and two covers on a bed. Let's get back to real football. And in January and February that means Real Cold Football.
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
Westbrook to the Redskins?
There is speculation going around now that Brian Westbrook may be heading to the Washington Redskins, where he would re-team with quarterback Donovan McNabb. For a long time it looked like Westbrook would be heading to St. Louis. If he lands in Washington it would be a steal.
Westbrook has been sidelined with injuries and concussions, so one big hit could end his career, or worse. But if he goes to Washington he would be sharing the load on an experienced team. It may be the thing his body needs to heal. Rest during the season. The Redskins have Clinton Portis, Willie Parker and Larry Johnson. Westbrook would be a spot player. But he has proven to be a playmaker, just not a durable one.
The Redskins offense needs an infusion of talent, and Westbrook would provide that. In the open field he is, and always has been, a dangerous runner. But my one worry is the history of concussions. Is it worth it for him to return? It may not be. But the will to play is strong in professional athletes. It's tough to get off the field willingly. Just look at Brett Favre. Year after year, the Favre Watch starts. This year it has been reported that he will need surgery on his ankle. Favre is 41 years old. His legacy is set. Does he need to come back and play again. No. But his will to play is still there, and Favre will most likely be wheeled off the field injured and broken.
Brian Westbrook on the Redskins would be a great addition if he can stay healthy. Brian Westbrook retired and doing commentary on the game he loves would be a smart move. Let's hope the smart move is the one he makes.
Westbrook has been sidelined with injuries and concussions, so one big hit could end his career, or worse. But if he goes to Washington he would be sharing the load on an experienced team. It may be the thing his body needs to heal. Rest during the season. The Redskins have Clinton Portis, Willie Parker and Larry Johnson. Westbrook would be a spot player. But he has proven to be a playmaker, just not a durable one.
The Redskins offense needs an infusion of talent, and Westbrook would provide that. In the open field he is, and always has been, a dangerous runner. But my one worry is the history of concussions. Is it worth it for him to return? It may not be. But the will to play is strong in professional athletes. It's tough to get off the field willingly. Just look at Brett Favre. Year after year, the Favre Watch starts. This year it has been reported that he will need surgery on his ankle. Favre is 41 years old. His legacy is set. Does he need to come back and play again. No. But his will to play is still there, and Favre will most likely be wheeled off the field injured and broken.
Brian Westbrook on the Redskins would be a great addition if he can stay healthy. Brian Westbrook retired and doing commentary on the game he loves would be a smart move. Let's hope the smart move is the one he makes.
Monday, May 10, 2010
Busted
Brian Cushing, the reigning NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year from the Houston Texans, has been suspended for the first four games of the 2010 NFL season after testing positive for a banned performance enhancing substance. There was speculation that he had tested positive at the NFL Scouting Combine in 2009. This suspension looks to have confirmed that point.
A suspension of four games comes after a SECOND positive test. Cushing claims that what he tested positive for was not a PED, but another substance that is on the banned list. I do have a question. If you have already tested positive once, wouldn't you get help from your team, your agent, your doctor, ANYONE, and find out what it is you can and cannot take?
The Texans are facing the toughest schedule of any team in the 2010 season. They have been notorious for being slow starters. Now they have to do it without one of their best players. But beyond that there is the psychological effect of the suspension. How many players are going to be thinking 'Not Again!' If they come out of the gates with just 1, or even zero wins in those first four games, will they be able to overcome the slow start to make a playoff run. It is going to put a load on the offense, and Matt Schaub will need to have an exceptional season if Houston is going to earn it's first playoff appearance.
There have also been some who are calling for the AP to withdraw the Defensive Rookie of the Year honor from Cushing. I say nonsense. Awards are given for play on the field, not behavior off the field afterwards. But I may change my mind when I find out what he tested positive for first. If it was a performance enhancing drug then you can make the argument. But right now it is speculation. But you do not need to speculate what is going to happen the first four games of the 2010 NFL season. Brian Cushing will be on the outside looking in. And the Houston Texans will be in a dogfight to make the playoffs because of it.
A suspension of four games comes after a SECOND positive test. Cushing claims that what he tested positive for was not a PED, but another substance that is on the banned list. I do have a question. If you have already tested positive once, wouldn't you get help from your team, your agent, your doctor, ANYONE, and find out what it is you can and cannot take?
The Texans are facing the toughest schedule of any team in the 2010 season. They have been notorious for being slow starters. Now they have to do it without one of their best players. But beyond that there is the psychological effect of the suspension. How many players are going to be thinking 'Not Again!' If they come out of the gates with just 1, or even zero wins in those first four games, will they be able to overcome the slow start to make a playoff run. It is going to put a load on the offense, and Matt Schaub will need to have an exceptional season if Houston is going to earn it's first playoff appearance.
There have also been some who are calling for the AP to withdraw the Defensive Rookie of the Year honor from Cushing. I say nonsense. Awards are given for play on the field, not behavior off the field afterwards. But I may change my mind when I find out what he tested positive for first. If it was a performance enhancing drug then you can make the argument. But right now it is speculation. But you do not need to speculate what is going to happen the first four games of the 2010 NFL season. Brian Cushing will be on the outside looking in. And the Houston Texans will be in a dogfight to make the playoffs because of it.
Sunday, May 9, 2010
Bringing changes with a new coach
Albert Haynesworth is not a happy camper. Although anyone who has signed a contract as big as the one he did in 2009 would be overjoyed to play football. But Albert is not happy.
When Mike Shanahan was announced as the new head coach of the Washington Redskins, the new regime made a decision to change the defensive alignment from a 4-3 to a 3-4. Haynesworth was not pleased with this as he is a 4-3 tackle, and has been since he came into the league with Tennessee. The more I think about this, the more I have to question why Shanahan would do this.
The Redskins problems were greater on the offensive side of the ball than the defensive. Washington was 10th in the NFL in 2009 in yards allowed/game. Brian Orakpo was outstanding in his rookie season, and they were 9th in sacks with 40. Now they want to change their defensive philosophy. It will be a big mistake if they do.
As good as Haynesworth has been, he may not be the dominant force in a 3-4. Orakpo may not be able to get to the quarterback as either a 3-4 end or outside linebacker. As good as these players are, they just can't turn a switch on and off and play a position they are not use to. If the Redskins defense plays the way they did in 2009 during the upcoming season, all they need is an offense to put some points on the board. Isn't that the reason they acquired Donovan McNabb, Larry Johnson, Willie Parker, and drafted Trent Williams.
Washington is making the necessary changes they need to make to be a playoff contender. But they would be better served leaving some things the same.
When Mike Shanahan was announced as the new head coach of the Washington Redskins, the new regime made a decision to change the defensive alignment from a 4-3 to a 3-4. Haynesworth was not pleased with this as he is a 4-3 tackle, and has been since he came into the league with Tennessee. The more I think about this, the more I have to question why Shanahan would do this.
The Redskins problems were greater on the offensive side of the ball than the defensive. Washington was 10th in the NFL in 2009 in yards allowed/game. Brian Orakpo was outstanding in his rookie season, and they were 9th in sacks with 40. Now they want to change their defensive philosophy. It will be a big mistake if they do.
As good as Haynesworth has been, he may not be the dominant force in a 3-4. Orakpo may not be able to get to the quarterback as either a 3-4 end or outside linebacker. As good as these players are, they just can't turn a switch on and off and play a position they are not use to. If the Redskins defense plays the way they did in 2009 during the upcoming season, all they need is an offense to put some points on the board. Isn't that the reason they acquired Donovan McNabb, Larry Johnson, Willie Parker, and drafted Trent Williams.
Washington is making the necessary changes they need to make to be a playoff contender. But they would be better served leaving some things the same.
Saturday, May 8, 2010
1st Overall QBs in the Spotlight
The release of JaMarcus Russell has once again put the spotlight on quarterbacks who have been selected 1st overall in the NFL Draft. Since the Common Draft started in 1967, there have been 18 quarterbacks selected first overall. But 10 of those 18 have been drafted since Peyton Manning went to the Colts in 1998. It makes a good dividing line as to which players have been successful, and which ones did not pan out.
In Group 1 (1967-1997), the picks were Terry Bradshaw, Jim Plunkett, Steve Bartkowski, John Elway, Vinnie Testaverde, Troy Aikman, Jeff George, and Drew Bledsoe. Bradshaw, Elway, and Aikman are Hall of Famers. Plunkett won 2 Super Bowls, and Bledsoe played on the 2001 Super Bowl Champion Patriots. But it was never easy for any one of the eight. Bradshaw started on the bench in 1974, the year Pittsburgh won it's first championship. Elway had to face the criticism of not wanting to play in Baltimore, and it was 14 years before he won the title. Aikman shared the job with Steve Walsh, and took a beating in a 1-15 rookie season. Plunkett didn't pan out in New England, and was traded to San Francisco. He washed out there, and landed in Oakland as a backup. He got his chance and in 1980 led the Raiders to the title, as well as in 1983.
Bartkowski battled injuries and some bad teams in Atlanta, but he made them into winners for the first time in their history. Testaverde had a less than distinguished career, playing for some of the worst teams in the league in Tampa Bay. But he played for nearly 20 years, with a number of teams. Bledsoe turned a bad Patriot franchise into a Super Bowl team in 1996, and it was his injury in 2001 that gave Tom Brady a chance. George was a workot wonder, who his hometown Colts traded a fortune to Atlanta so they could take him in 1990. George had the most problems of any quarterback in this group, mainly because his value was overrated by the team that drafted him.
But the biggest difference between the first 8 and the last 10 is money. The advent of the rookie signing bonus has shined the spotlight even brighter than before. Russell received a $31 million bonus, and won a total of 7 games. But the situations a number of them have been put into is not a recipe for success.
Tim Couch and David Carr were selected by expansion franchises. Both players took a beating playing behind an offensive line of castoffs. Matthew Stafford had his rookie season interrupted by injuries. Alex Smith has also been injured, but he also has had difficutly with the switch from a spread offense to a pro style system, but he show flashes in 2009 that he is ready to fulfill his promise. Michael Vick showed flashes of brilliance, but two years in prison has sidetracked his career. The Manning Brothers each have a Super Bowl title, and Peyton is on his way to rewriting the record books.
What does this hold for Sam Bradford? First of all, the Rams need to have him signed and in training camp on time. Russell was a holdout, and his development was stunted because of it, not to mention his lack of work ethic. It may be in the best interest for the Rams to do with Bradford what Cincinnati did with Carson Palmer. Sit him out his rookie year. Give him a chance to learn the pro system. Give his shoulder a year to get stronger. Is endangering a rookie with a $45 million signing bonus the best thing for the franchise? At this time it may not be. But if the Rams want to stay in St. Louis they may want to put Bradford on the field and get fans in the stands.
One thing Bardford has in his favor at this time is that if he is just an average quarterback he will be held in higher regard than Couch, Vick, Carr, Smith and Russell. But how he handles the spotlight reamins to be seen.
In Group 1 (1967-1997), the picks were Terry Bradshaw, Jim Plunkett, Steve Bartkowski, John Elway, Vinnie Testaverde, Troy Aikman, Jeff George, and Drew Bledsoe. Bradshaw, Elway, and Aikman are Hall of Famers. Plunkett won 2 Super Bowls, and Bledsoe played on the 2001 Super Bowl Champion Patriots. But it was never easy for any one of the eight. Bradshaw started on the bench in 1974, the year Pittsburgh won it's first championship. Elway had to face the criticism of not wanting to play in Baltimore, and it was 14 years before he won the title. Aikman shared the job with Steve Walsh, and took a beating in a 1-15 rookie season. Plunkett didn't pan out in New England, and was traded to San Francisco. He washed out there, and landed in Oakland as a backup. He got his chance and in 1980 led the Raiders to the title, as well as in 1983.
Bartkowski battled injuries and some bad teams in Atlanta, but he made them into winners for the first time in their history. Testaverde had a less than distinguished career, playing for some of the worst teams in the league in Tampa Bay. But he played for nearly 20 years, with a number of teams. Bledsoe turned a bad Patriot franchise into a Super Bowl team in 1996, and it was his injury in 2001 that gave Tom Brady a chance. George was a workot wonder, who his hometown Colts traded a fortune to Atlanta so they could take him in 1990. George had the most problems of any quarterback in this group, mainly because his value was overrated by the team that drafted him.
But the biggest difference between the first 8 and the last 10 is money. The advent of the rookie signing bonus has shined the spotlight even brighter than before. Russell received a $31 million bonus, and won a total of 7 games. But the situations a number of them have been put into is not a recipe for success.
Tim Couch and David Carr were selected by expansion franchises. Both players took a beating playing behind an offensive line of castoffs. Matthew Stafford had his rookie season interrupted by injuries. Alex Smith has also been injured, but he also has had difficutly with the switch from a spread offense to a pro style system, but he show flashes in 2009 that he is ready to fulfill his promise. Michael Vick showed flashes of brilliance, but two years in prison has sidetracked his career. The Manning Brothers each have a Super Bowl title, and Peyton is on his way to rewriting the record books.
What does this hold for Sam Bradford? First of all, the Rams need to have him signed and in training camp on time. Russell was a holdout, and his development was stunted because of it, not to mention his lack of work ethic. It may be in the best interest for the Rams to do with Bradford what Cincinnati did with Carson Palmer. Sit him out his rookie year. Give him a chance to learn the pro system. Give his shoulder a year to get stronger. Is endangering a rookie with a $45 million signing bonus the best thing for the franchise? At this time it may not be. But if the Rams want to stay in St. Louis they may want to put Bradford on the field and get fans in the stands.
One thing Bardford has in his favor at this time is that if he is just an average quarterback he will be held in higher regard than Couch, Vick, Carr, Smith and Russell. But how he handles the spotlight reamins to be seen.
Friday, May 7, 2010
St. Louis Rams beef up the defense
It has been announced that the St. Louis Rams and Dallas Cowboys have finalized a trade that will send offensive tackle Alex Barron from St. Louis to the Cowboys for linebacker Bobby Carpenter. This is one instance that both teams will come out on the good side of the trade, but I like what the Rams are getting for their defense.
Barron will most likely move into the left tackle position left vacant by the release of Flozell Adams. The Cowboys drafted Sam Young from Notre Dame and it is possible he is moving into the position after he gets his legs under him in the NFL. Dallas also drafted Sean Lee in the second round, and he looks to move into the starting lineup as well. But unless Young can make the transition to the pro game Dallas will be looking to find a long term solution to the left tackle position. Barron has been a solid player but his best years seem to be behind him.
Which is one reason why the Rams drafted Rodger Saffold in the second round of the 2010 NFL Draft. They saw him as the bookend to 2009 first round pick Jason Smith and now they have a pair of young tackles they can build their offense around. Now with Carpenter joining former Ohio State teammate James Laurinaitis in the linebacker corps their defense gets a shot of youth that it will need. The Rams defense was horrific in 2009, and Carpenter can help solidify the unit. He never did find his place in Dallas. A fresh start in St. Louis can help him live up to his first round draft billing.
It's not often that a one-for-one trade helps both teams. This one does. I feel that in the long run it will help the Rams more than most people think at this time.
Barron will most likely move into the left tackle position left vacant by the release of Flozell Adams. The Cowboys drafted Sam Young from Notre Dame and it is possible he is moving into the position after he gets his legs under him in the NFL. Dallas also drafted Sean Lee in the second round, and he looks to move into the starting lineup as well. But unless Young can make the transition to the pro game Dallas will be looking to find a long term solution to the left tackle position. Barron has been a solid player but his best years seem to be behind him.
Which is one reason why the Rams drafted Rodger Saffold in the second round of the 2010 NFL Draft. They saw him as the bookend to 2009 first round pick Jason Smith and now they have a pair of young tackles they can build their offense around. Now with Carpenter joining former Ohio State teammate James Laurinaitis in the linebacker corps their defense gets a shot of youth that it will need. The Rams defense was horrific in 2009, and Carpenter can help solidify the unit. He never did find his place in Dallas. A fresh start in St. Louis can help him live up to his first round draft billing.
It's not often that a one-for-one trade helps both teams. This one does. I feel that in the long run it will help the Rams more than most people think at this time.
Thursday, May 6, 2010
The Debate over the Biggest Draft Bust Ever
It's official. The JaMarcus Russell era has ended in Oakland. And it may be over for good. As I have written before, I don't see any team picking him up. Why would they? He never did show any semblance of a work ethic, was never in shape and never seemed to pick up the offense of be able to read defenses. Unless there is a miraculous comeback, Russell could very well go down as the biggest draft bust ever.
In the annals of the NFL, the biggest draft busts are quarterbacks. They are the marquee players, and being in the spotlight makes them easy targets for criticism. But when their performance doesn't reflect their draft status, they get the label of draft bust.
You can go back to 1979, when the Cincinnati Bengals selected Jack Thompson #3 overall. It was believed that Ken Anderson was at the end of his career, but Thompson never did play well. Anderson revived his career under Forrest Gregg, and led the Bengals to the Super Bowl in 1981. Thompson was eventually traded to Tampa Bay, and was out of the league before you realized he was in.
Twenty years later the Bengals selected Akili Smith with the #3 overall selection. He didn't are any better than Thompson. He held out, never did pick up the offense and had trouble reading defenses (sounds a lot like Russell, doesn't it?) Smith was released when Marvin Lewis came in and drafted Carson Palmer #1 overall in 2003. He failed to find a home in the NFL and like Thompson was out of the league in a hurry.
In the 90's, the quarterback bust list was long. Heath Shuler and Rick Mirer failed badly in the NFL. Tim Couch and Cade McNown were in the same draft class as Smith, and didn't fare any better. But the bust that everyone else is measured against is Ryan Leaf.
His bust status is so high because some people actually had him graded higher than Peyton Manning. I imagine that those personnel staffers are no longer working in the NFL. San Diego traded up 1 spot to draft Leaf, and gave up a number of picks to do it. Which never made sense to me because Arizona already had Jake Plummer at quarterback, and they had no reason to draft Leaf except as leverage. Then Leaf took the field, and was a disaster. He was even worse off the field. The less I say the better. He is simply put the poster boy for bad behavior.
It will be seen as to whether or not Russell will be a bigger draft bust than Russell. But if he doesn't get picked up by another team to prove himself I'd say yes, the Biggest Draft Bust EVER.
In the annals of the NFL, the biggest draft busts are quarterbacks. They are the marquee players, and being in the spotlight makes them easy targets for criticism. But when their performance doesn't reflect their draft status, they get the label of draft bust.
You can go back to 1979, when the Cincinnati Bengals selected Jack Thompson #3 overall. It was believed that Ken Anderson was at the end of his career, but Thompson never did play well. Anderson revived his career under Forrest Gregg, and led the Bengals to the Super Bowl in 1981. Thompson was eventually traded to Tampa Bay, and was out of the league before you realized he was in.
Twenty years later the Bengals selected Akili Smith with the #3 overall selection. He didn't are any better than Thompson. He held out, never did pick up the offense and had trouble reading defenses (sounds a lot like Russell, doesn't it?) Smith was released when Marvin Lewis came in and drafted Carson Palmer #1 overall in 2003. He failed to find a home in the NFL and like Thompson was out of the league in a hurry.
In the 90's, the quarterback bust list was long. Heath Shuler and Rick Mirer failed badly in the NFL. Tim Couch and Cade McNown were in the same draft class as Smith, and didn't fare any better. But the bust that everyone else is measured against is Ryan Leaf.
His bust status is so high because some people actually had him graded higher than Peyton Manning. I imagine that those personnel staffers are no longer working in the NFL. San Diego traded up 1 spot to draft Leaf, and gave up a number of picks to do it. Which never made sense to me because Arizona already had Jake Plummer at quarterback, and they had no reason to draft Leaf except as leverage. Then Leaf took the field, and was a disaster. He was even worse off the field. The less I say the better. He is simply put the poster boy for bad behavior.
It will be seen as to whether or not Russell will be a bigger draft bust than Russell. But if he doesn't get picked up by another team to prove himself I'd say yes, the Biggest Draft Bust EVER.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Pacman and the Bengals. A match made in...?
It has come out that Pacman Jones, the former 6th overall selection of the 2005 NFL Draft, who has been out of the NFL since 2008 because of repeated bad behavior and violation of the league's Personal Conduct Policy, is going to sign a contract with the Cincinnati Bengals. Many will say that the two deserve each other. The Bengals have had a number of players in trouble with the league and the law, and have taken in just as many who have had problems when they played on other teams. Now it looks like they have another in Jones.
But the question here isn't why the Bengals are signing him. Mike Brown is a self proclaimed 'redeemer.' He took Chris Henry back in after releasing him and after the league suspended the receiver. He has given Cedric Benson, Tank Johnson and Matt Jones another chance. The Bengals even offered Michael Vick a contract, but he signed with Philadelphia instead. Now they are bringing in Adam "Pacman" Jones. Mike Brown will be the patron saint of redeemers if Jones performs well with Cincinnati.
But for me the question is "What position will Jones play, and can he even make the team?" Jones is a cornerback. The Bengals have one of the best pair of young corners in Jonathon Joseph and Leon Hall. They have second year player Morgan Trent, and used a 3rd round pick in the 2010 NFL Draft on Brandon Ghee. Jones was a feared punt returner in his time with the Tennessee Titans. The Bengals have Quan Cosby, who averaged nearly 12 yards per punt return in 2009. Bernard Scott returned kickoffs, and ran one back for a touchdown against Pittsburgh that was the difference in the game. They also drafted Jordan Shipley in the 3rd round, and he returned kicks at Texas. The two positions that Jones played the best are well covered.
There is one position he might have a shot with in Cincinnati. Safety. The Bengals did not draft a safety in 2010, but they are looking to sign Gibril Wilson. Jones seemed to have lost a step or 2 when he was in Dallas, and if has bulked up then safety may be the position for him. He may be undersized in run support, but in pass coverage he could excel. He would be covering tight ends and backs who are going to be slower then the receivers on the outside, and if his cover skills are still there he would be perfect for nickel and dime coverage packages.
If the Bengals can bring the tough love to Jones that he needs, and if he buys into the words of Head Coach Marvin Lewis and defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, then Jones will be a bargain for the Bengals. Now all they have to do is keep him out of trouble off the field. That may be the toughest task awaiting Mike Brown's Team of Redemption.
But the question here isn't why the Bengals are signing him. Mike Brown is a self proclaimed 'redeemer.' He took Chris Henry back in after releasing him and after the league suspended the receiver. He has given Cedric Benson, Tank Johnson and Matt Jones another chance. The Bengals even offered Michael Vick a contract, but he signed with Philadelphia instead. Now they are bringing in Adam "Pacman" Jones. Mike Brown will be the patron saint of redeemers if Jones performs well with Cincinnati.
But for me the question is "What position will Jones play, and can he even make the team?" Jones is a cornerback. The Bengals have one of the best pair of young corners in Jonathon Joseph and Leon Hall. They have second year player Morgan Trent, and used a 3rd round pick in the 2010 NFL Draft on Brandon Ghee. Jones was a feared punt returner in his time with the Tennessee Titans. The Bengals have Quan Cosby, who averaged nearly 12 yards per punt return in 2009. Bernard Scott returned kickoffs, and ran one back for a touchdown against Pittsburgh that was the difference in the game. They also drafted Jordan Shipley in the 3rd round, and he returned kicks at Texas. The two positions that Jones played the best are well covered.
There is one position he might have a shot with in Cincinnati. Safety. The Bengals did not draft a safety in 2010, but they are looking to sign Gibril Wilson. Jones seemed to have lost a step or 2 when he was in Dallas, and if has bulked up then safety may be the position for him. He may be undersized in run support, but in pass coverage he could excel. He would be covering tight ends and backs who are going to be slower then the receivers on the outside, and if his cover skills are still there he would be perfect for nickel and dime coverage packages.
If the Bengals can bring the tough love to Jones that he needs, and if he buys into the words of Head Coach Marvin Lewis and defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, then Jones will be a bargain for the Bengals. Now all they have to do is keep him out of trouble off the field. That may be the toughest task awaiting Mike Brown's Team of Redemption.
Tuesday, May 4, 2010
Judged by the Quarterbacks
As it is in every NFL Draft, the marquee players are the quarterbacks. It doesn't matter if they are the highest rated players, or if they are expected to have the most successful careers. The quarterback is the face of the NFL, and when the draft comes around the quarterbacks are caught in the glare.
The 2010 NFL Draft had four quarterbacks that were the focus from the start. Sam Bradford was the 2008 Heisman Trophy winner from Oklahoma, but he missed most of the 2009 season with a serious shoulder injury. Tim Tebow was the 2007 Heisman Trophy winner from Florida and a 2-Time National Champion, but was seen as a system quarterback with flawed mechanics.
Jimmy Clausen was the quarterback of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish. That position shines in the spotlight like no other, and with his physical skills Clausen could not carry Notre Dame to the top of college football. Colt McCoy finished his career at Texas as the winningest quarterback in college history, but he came up short in the BCS National Championship, as he suffered a shoulder injury early in the game against Alabama and did not get his chance to win the title.
The questions started to fly as soon a the season ended. Bradford answered his during his pro day workout. His arm strength was there and the accuracy never went away. At the end of the day it was not a question as to whether St. Louis would select him #1 overall, but whether the would have him signed before the draft.
Tebow began working on his throwing motion and shortening his delivery. His pro day workout showed a more compact delivery, but many wondered if he would revert to his old ways under the pressure of an NFL pass rush. He seemed to convince many that he was on his way to becoming an NFL quarterback.
Clausen had an injury of his own to deal with in 2009, a toe injury that was still bothering him during his pro day workout. But his arm strength and accuracy was still there, and he had prospects of going high in the draft. McCoy showed off his arm strength during his pro day workout, and many were seeing his draft stock rise.
On draft day, Bradford was indeed the #1 overall selection by St. Louis. Washington was out of the quarterback derby when the traded for Donovan McNabb. The next teams looking for a quarterback were Cleveland and Buffalo. They both passed. Many were wondering how far down the first round Clausen would fall. Turns out it was a long way.
Denver pulled the big surprise by selecting Tebow #25 overall. Many had Tebow moving into the first round, but it was a surprise that Denver, who has Kyle Orton as the starter and who traded for Brady Quinn in the offseason, would take Tebow in the first round. They traded three draft picks to move back into the round, and in doing so placed even more expectations on the shoulders of Tebow.
Clausen fell into Round 2, going 48th overall to Carolina. Many feel that he may be in the best situation. He is with a team that has Matt Moore at the starting quarterback position, a strong running game, a playmaker in Steve Smith at wide receiver, and a strong offensive line. Clausen has a luxury of being able to wait and learn without the expectations that are being heaped on Bradford and Tebow.
McCoy had to wait until Round 3, going to Cleveland with the 85th overall selection. Mike Holmgren has come out and said that McCoy won't even play in 2010. He is taking the approach that he will be best served by sitting and learning. But if things are not working out for the Browns I wonder if his timetable will get moved up.
I believed going into the draft that Clausen had the best chance for success in the NFL, and I see that happening under the current circumstances of the four quarterbacks. But even with Ndamukong Suh, Gerald McCoy, Eric Berry and others, the 2010 NFL Draft will be seen as a success or failure as the fates of the four quarterbacks develop over the years.
The 2010 NFL Draft had four quarterbacks that were the focus from the start. Sam Bradford was the 2008 Heisman Trophy winner from Oklahoma, but he missed most of the 2009 season with a serious shoulder injury. Tim Tebow was the 2007 Heisman Trophy winner from Florida and a 2-Time National Champion, but was seen as a system quarterback with flawed mechanics.
Jimmy Clausen was the quarterback of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish. That position shines in the spotlight like no other, and with his physical skills Clausen could not carry Notre Dame to the top of college football. Colt McCoy finished his career at Texas as the winningest quarterback in college history, but he came up short in the BCS National Championship, as he suffered a shoulder injury early in the game against Alabama and did not get his chance to win the title.
The questions started to fly as soon a the season ended. Bradford answered his during his pro day workout. His arm strength was there and the accuracy never went away. At the end of the day it was not a question as to whether St. Louis would select him #1 overall, but whether the would have him signed before the draft.
Tebow began working on his throwing motion and shortening his delivery. His pro day workout showed a more compact delivery, but many wondered if he would revert to his old ways under the pressure of an NFL pass rush. He seemed to convince many that he was on his way to becoming an NFL quarterback.
Clausen had an injury of his own to deal with in 2009, a toe injury that was still bothering him during his pro day workout. But his arm strength and accuracy was still there, and he had prospects of going high in the draft. McCoy showed off his arm strength during his pro day workout, and many were seeing his draft stock rise.
On draft day, Bradford was indeed the #1 overall selection by St. Louis. Washington was out of the quarterback derby when the traded for Donovan McNabb. The next teams looking for a quarterback were Cleveland and Buffalo. They both passed. Many were wondering how far down the first round Clausen would fall. Turns out it was a long way.
Denver pulled the big surprise by selecting Tebow #25 overall. Many had Tebow moving into the first round, but it was a surprise that Denver, who has Kyle Orton as the starter and who traded for Brady Quinn in the offseason, would take Tebow in the first round. They traded three draft picks to move back into the round, and in doing so placed even more expectations on the shoulders of Tebow.
Clausen fell into Round 2, going 48th overall to Carolina. Many feel that he may be in the best situation. He is with a team that has Matt Moore at the starting quarterback position, a strong running game, a playmaker in Steve Smith at wide receiver, and a strong offensive line. Clausen has a luxury of being able to wait and learn without the expectations that are being heaped on Bradford and Tebow.
McCoy had to wait until Round 3, going to Cleveland with the 85th overall selection. Mike Holmgren has come out and said that McCoy won't even play in 2010. He is taking the approach that he will be best served by sitting and learning. But if things are not working out for the Browns I wonder if his timetable will get moved up.
I believed going into the draft that Clausen had the best chance for success in the NFL, and I see that happening under the current circumstances of the four quarterbacks. But even with Ndamukong Suh, Gerald McCoy, Eric Berry and others, the 2010 NFL Draft will be seen as a success or failure as the fates of the four quarterbacks develop over the years.
Monday, May 3, 2010
The Curious Case of JaMarcus Russell
The Oakland Raiders had, by all accounts, a successful draft. A hard hitting middle linebacker. A versatile defensive lineman. Two promising bookend tackles. And to cap it off they made a trade to settle their quarterback situation.
When it was announced that the Raiders traded for Jason Campbell, Head Coach Tom Cable came out and announced that Campbell would be the starter. The incumbent quarterback, JaMarcus Russell, seemed to be on his way out of town. The only question was when.
Then a curious thing happened. Tom Cable discovered that he does not have as much pull with the team as he thought. Now Cable has come out and stated that there will be an open competition for the starting quarterback job. The man with all the power in the organization had to have told Cable that JaMarcus Russell still has a job, and that man is Al Davis.
When the Russell Release Watch started, you could find video all over the place of Al Davis at the infamous news conference after he fired Lane Kiffen making a statement that Kiffen wanted to draft Calvin Johnson, and that even though Kiffen didn't want Russell, that he was the starting quarterback. Get over it. I wonder how many times Davis watched this.
Davis had to have seen it and thought 'No one tells me what to do here!' So Russell stays with the Raiders and gets his roster bonus. It doesn't matter that Russell has been an unmitigated bust. No one tells Al Davis what to do.
For his credit, Russell has come out ans stated the he is going to work his butt off. The problem is that his lack of work ethic has enabled his butt to get so big that he probably never will be able to work it back into decent playing shape. Now the Raiders have a problem that many teams have had over the years and never did handle properly. They have 2 quarterbacks. And when you have 2 quarterbacks you don't have A QUARTERBACK.
I have always liked Jason Campbell. I think he is in a situation out in Oakland where he can get settled into the starters position and be the quarterback that the Redskins thought he would be when they drafted him in the first round back in 2005. Now his hardest task awaits. He needs to convince Al Davis that he is the man for the job. I don't see it happening any time soon.
When it was announced that the Raiders traded for Jason Campbell, Head Coach Tom Cable came out and announced that Campbell would be the starter. The incumbent quarterback, JaMarcus Russell, seemed to be on his way out of town. The only question was when.
Then a curious thing happened. Tom Cable discovered that he does not have as much pull with the team as he thought. Now Cable has come out and stated that there will be an open competition for the starting quarterback job. The man with all the power in the organization had to have told Cable that JaMarcus Russell still has a job, and that man is Al Davis.
When the Russell Release Watch started, you could find video all over the place of Al Davis at the infamous news conference after he fired Lane Kiffen making a statement that Kiffen wanted to draft Calvin Johnson, and that even though Kiffen didn't want Russell, that he was the starting quarterback. Get over it. I wonder how many times Davis watched this.
Davis had to have seen it and thought 'No one tells me what to do here!' So Russell stays with the Raiders and gets his roster bonus. It doesn't matter that Russell has been an unmitigated bust. No one tells Al Davis what to do.
For his credit, Russell has come out ans stated the he is going to work his butt off. The problem is that his lack of work ethic has enabled his butt to get so big that he probably never will be able to work it back into decent playing shape. Now the Raiders have a problem that many teams have had over the years and never did handle properly. They have 2 quarterbacks. And when you have 2 quarterbacks you don't have A QUARTERBACK.
I have always liked Jason Campbell. I think he is in a situation out in Oakland where he can get settled into the starters position and be the quarterback that the Redskins thought he would be when they drafted him in the first round back in 2005. Now his hardest task awaits. He needs to convince Al Davis that he is the man for the job. I don't see it happening any time soon.
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Draft Grades: Washington Redskins
The Washington Redskins went into the 2010 NFL Draft with big questions on offense. Was Jason Campbell the quarterback of the future? Who is going to block for whoever was taking snaps at quarterback? One question was answered before the draft, the other on draft day.
The Redskins traded for Donovan McNabb before the draft, and then traded Campbell to Oakland for a 4th round pick in 2012. The offensive line question was answered with the 4th overall selection, as Washington selected Trent Williams. Many draft experts had Russell Okung going to the Redskins, but Williams was the most athletic tackle in the draft, and seen as a better fit for their system.
Because of trades the Redskins did not have another pick until the 4th round. Perry Riley was the pick in Round 4, and he can move into a middle linebacker position on defense.
Late round sleepers look to be Erik Cook and Selvish Capers, a pair of offensive lineman. The line was a major weak spot in 2009, and Cook and Capers may be able to find starting spots along with Williams as the line looks to be revamped.
Draft Grade: C+
The Redskins traded for Donovan McNabb before the draft, and then traded Campbell to Oakland for a 4th round pick in 2012. The offensive line question was answered with the 4th overall selection, as Washington selected Trent Williams. Many draft experts had Russell Okung going to the Redskins, but Williams was the most athletic tackle in the draft, and seen as a better fit for their system.
Because of trades the Redskins did not have another pick until the 4th round. Perry Riley was the pick in Round 4, and he can move into a middle linebacker position on defense.
Late round sleepers look to be Erik Cook and Selvish Capers, a pair of offensive lineman. The line was a major weak spot in 2009, and Cook and Capers may be able to find starting spots along with Williams as the line looks to be revamped.
Draft Grade: C+
Draft Grades: Tennessee Titans
The Tennessee Titans finished the 2008 regular season with the best record in the NFL, but a loss in the divisional round of the playoffs left a sour taste on a season where everything seemed to be coming together. Then the 2009 season started with a long losing streak, and when Vince Young was reinstated as the starter it was too late to salvage the season. The Titans went into the 2010 NFL Draft looking to add to their success at the end of the previous year.
Tennessee needed to add a pass rusher, and they were able to select the player many saw as the best defensive end in the draft in Derrick Morgan. The Titans pass rush has suffered since the departure of Jevon Kearse, and Morgan will help the defense get pressure on the quarterback.
With Chris Johnson in the backfield, the Titans were looking to find a wide receiver to help strengthen the passing game and take some of the pressure off of Johnson. Tennessee selected Damian Williams in the third round. Williams will also be looked upon to return punts and kicks. The Titans traded up to select Alterraun Verner, a cornerback fro UCLA. Verner will be able to compete for a starting position in the secondary.
A late round sleeper pick looks to be Myron Rolle, a safety from Florida State. Rolle may be the first example of a player whose draft stock dropped because he is TOO smart. A Rhodes Scholar, Rolle spent the last year in England studying medicine but he is committed to playing football. Rolle can make an impact on special teams and in nickel packages, and his presence in the locker room can serve as a reminder to other young players what you can accomplish life outside of football.
Draft Grade: B
Tennessee needed to add a pass rusher, and they were able to select the player many saw as the best defensive end in the draft in Derrick Morgan. The Titans pass rush has suffered since the departure of Jevon Kearse, and Morgan will help the defense get pressure on the quarterback.
With Chris Johnson in the backfield, the Titans were looking to find a wide receiver to help strengthen the passing game and take some of the pressure off of Johnson. Tennessee selected Damian Williams in the third round. Williams will also be looked upon to return punts and kicks. The Titans traded up to select Alterraun Verner, a cornerback fro UCLA. Verner will be able to compete for a starting position in the secondary.
A late round sleeper pick looks to be Myron Rolle, a safety from Florida State. Rolle may be the first example of a player whose draft stock dropped because he is TOO smart. A Rhodes Scholar, Rolle spent the last year in England studying medicine but he is committed to playing football. Rolle can make an impact on special teams and in nickel packages, and his presence in the locker room can serve as a reminder to other young players what you can accomplish life outside of football.
Draft Grade: B
Draft Grades: Tampa Bay Buccaneers
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers just missed the playoffs in 2008, and went into a rebulding mode instead of reloading. A new coach, a rookie quarterback, and changes on both sides of the ball brought the Bucs a 3-13 record, and the third pick in the 2010 NFL Draft. There were holes to fill on both sides of the ball, and Tampa Bay found players who can have an immediate impact.
The 3rd overall selection was used on Gerald McCoy, a defensive tackle from Oklahoma. A number of draft experts had McCoy rated ahead of Ndamukong Suh, and McCoy is seen as the heir apparent to Warren Sapp. The second round brought another defensive tackle in Brian Price. McCoy and Price play different styles, and they should compliment each other well in the middle of the defensive line.
2009 first round selection Josh Freeman discovered that if you don't have quality receivers to throw to the passing game in the NFL can be difficult. That area was addressed with the selection of Arrelious Benn in Round 2. Another receiver, Mike Williams from Syracuse, was taken in the 4th round but he had a number of off the field problems in college, but he was seen by many as possibly the most talented receiver in the draft.
A late round sleeper could be Cody Grimm, a safety from Virginia Tech. The son of former Redskins lineman Russ Grimm, Cody is a hard nosed, tough minded player who plays with a high motor all the time.
Draft Grade: B+
The 3rd overall selection was used on Gerald McCoy, a defensive tackle from Oklahoma. A number of draft experts had McCoy rated ahead of Ndamukong Suh, and McCoy is seen as the heir apparent to Warren Sapp. The second round brought another defensive tackle in Brian Price. McCoy and Price play different styles, and they should compliment each other well in the middle of the defensive line.
2009 first round selection Josh Freeman discovered that if you don't have quality receivers to throw to the passing game in the NFL can be difficult. That area was addressed with the selection of Arrelious Benn in Round 2. Another receiver, Mike Williams from Syracuse, was taken in the 4th round but he had a number of off the field problems in college, but he was seen by many as possibly the most talented receiver in the draft.
A late round sleeper could be Cody Grimm, a safety from Virginia Tech. The son of former Redskins lineman Russ Grimm, Cody is a hard nosed, tough minded player who plays with a high motor all the time.
Draft Grade: B+
Draft Grades: St. Louis Rams
The St. Louis Rams franchise is a shell of its former self. They have won a total of 6 games in the last 3 seasons, and after a 1-15 season in 2009 the Rams had the 1st overall selection in the 2010 NFL Draft. The previous two drafts had the Rams passing on a franchise quarterback, and after the pro day workout of Sam Bradford there was no question who St. Louis would select at the top of the 2010 NFL Draft.
Bradford was indeed the 1st overall selection, and he is expected to be the face of the franchise. But he will have to get acclimated to taking snaps under center, and there will always be persistent questions about the health of his shoulder. The Rams selected Jason Smith 2nd overall in 2009, and he will be the Rams left tackle protecting Bradford's blind side. The second round in 2010 brought the Rams their right tackle of the future.
Rodger Saffold was seen as a late first round talent, and his selection may end up being more valuable to the Rams over time. Not only will he be able to pass block for Bradford, but he will also be able to open holes for Steven Jackson to run through. The more effective the Rams running game is, the more effective Bradford will be in the passing game.
Bradford also got a couple of targets to throw to later in the draft. Mardy Gilyard fell all the way to the top of the fourth round, and Michael Hoomanawanui should help shore up the tight end position.
The Rams also need help on the defensive side of the ball, and they got a late round sleeper in George Selvie. His production has never matched his talent, and if St. Louis can get him to produce then they can line him up opposite of Chris Long and rush the passer from both sides.
Draft Grade: B+
Bradford was indeed the 1st overall selection, and he is expected to be the face of the franchise. But he will have to get acclimated to taking snaps under center, and there will always be persistent questions about the health of his shoulder. The Rams selected Jason Smith 2nd overall in 2009, and he will be the Rams left tackle protecting Bradford's blind side. The second round in 2010 brought the Rams their right tackle of the future.
Rodger Saffold was seen as a late first round talent, and his selection may end up being more valuable to the Rams over time. Not only will he be able to pass block for Bradford, but he will also be able to open holes for Steven Jackson to run through. The more effective the Rams running game is, the more effective Bradford will be in the passing game.
Bradford also got a couple of targets to throw to later in the draft. Mardy Gilyard fell all the way to the top of the fourth round, and Michael Hoomanawanui should help shore up the tight end position.
The Rams also need help on the defensive side of the ball, and they got a late round sleeper in George Selvie. His production has never matched his talent, and if St. Louis can get him to produce then they can line him up opposite of Chris Long and rush the passer from both sides.
Draft Grade: B+
Draft Grades: Seattle Seahawks
The Seattle Seahawks are coming off of a 4-12 season in which two cornerstones of the franchise spent much of the season injured. Matt Hasslebeck and Walter Jones help lead the Seahawks to the Super Bowl in 2005, but their lack of playing time in 2009 was evident. Seattle went out during the offseason and acquired Charlie Whitehurst from San Diego. Whitehurst looks to be the quarterback of the future, but he is still a question mark as he has not thrown a pass in 4 NFL seasons.
The draft addressed the void left by the retirement of Jones. You don't replace a Hall of Fame left tackle overnight, but Seattle was able to select the tackle many had at the top of their draft boards in Russell Okung with the 6th overall selection. With a second pick in the first round Seattle was then able to pick Earl Thomas, a safety from Texas that some had rated higher than Eric Berry, who went 5th overall. Thomas is strongest in pass coverage, and he has the ability to play cornerback as well.
The Whitehurst trade cost Seattle their regular second round pick higher up in that round, but it also brought the Chargers pick at near the end of the second round. With that selection Seattle got one of the biggest steals of the draft when they were able to select Golden Tate. The wide receiver from Notre Dame was seen by many as the #1 or #2 wideout in the draft, and with injuries to T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Deion Branch it looks like Tate will get a chance to play right away.
Seattle also got two late round sleepers in Kam Chancellor and Anthony McCoy. Chancellor can team up with Earl Thomas and the two of them will be patrolling the secondary for many years to come. McCoy is a big, physical tight end who can block as well as catch passes, and his draft stock fell due to a positive drug test at the NFL Scouting Combine. But his old college coach from USC was Pete Carroll, who now coaches the Seahawks. Carroll knows what he is getting with McCoy, and if he can stay clean then Seattle got a tight end who will help solidify their passing game.
Draft Grade: A+ (Best Draft of any team in 2010)
The draft addressed the void left by the retirement of Jones. You don't replace a Hall of Fame left tackle overnight, but Seattle was able to select the tackle many had at the top of their draft boards in Russell Okung with the 6th overall selection. With a second pick in the first round Seattle was then able to pick Earl Thomas, a safety from Texas that some had rated higher than Eric Berry, who went 5th overall. Thomas is strongest in pass coverage, and he has the ability to play cornerback as well.
The Whitehurst trade cost Seattle their regular second round pick higher up in that round, but it also brought the Chargers pick at near the end of the second round. With that selection Seattle got one of the biggest steals of the draft when they were able to select Golden Tate. The wide receiver from Notre Dame was seen by many as the #1 or #2 wideout in the draft, and with injuries to T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Deion Branch it looks like Tate will get a chance to play right away.
Seattle also got two late round sleepers in Kam Chancellor and Anthony McCoy. Chancellor can team up with Earl Thomas and the two of them will be patrolling the secondary for many years to come. McCoy is a big, physical tight end who can block as well as catch passes, and his draft stock fell due to a positive drug test at the NFL Scouting Combine. But his old college coach from USC was Pete Carroll, who now coaches the Seahawks. Carroll knows what he is getting with McCoy, and if he can stay clean then Seattle got a tight end who will help solidify their passing game.
Draft Grade: A+ (Best Draft of any team in 2010)
Saturday, May 1, 2010
Draft Grades: San Francisco 49ers
The San Francisco 49ers finished the 2009 season at 8-8. It marked an improvement and the team looks to be buying into the way Mike Singletary coaches and they are starting to take the field in the image of their coach. The 2010 NFL Draft brought players who fit the mold Singletary of making the 49ers in to.
With two first round selections, the 49ers picked offensive lineman Anthony Davis and Mike Iupati. Both are big, physical blockers who will help plow the road for Frank Gore and the running game. With Joe Staley on the left side, Davis and Iupati will provide cornerstones for years to come.
The second round pick brought Taylor Mays, a safety from USC. Many see Mays as a liability in the pass game, but I believe that Singletary wants Mays to swing the hammer and be the hitter at safety that he played with in Chicago, namely Doug Plank and Gary Fencik. With his size and speed, Mays will almost be another linebacker in support of the run. The third round brought Navorro Bowman, a linebacker from Penn State who was graded with late first round/early second round talent who fell due to off the field issues.
A late round sleeper looks to be Anthony Dixon, a running back from Mississippi State. Dixon is the power back who can spell Gore and give the 49ers the punishing ground game that Coach Singletary is looking to establish.
Draft Grade: A
With two first round selections, the 49ers picked offensive lineman Anthony Davis and Mike Iupati. Both are big, physical blockers who will help plow the road for Frank Gore and the running game. With Joe Staley on the left side, Davis and Iupati will provide cornerstones for years to come.
The second round pick brought Taylor Mays, a safety from USC. Many see Mays as a liability in the pass game, but I believe that Singletary wants Mays to swing the hammer and be the hitter at safety that he played with in Chicago, namely Doug Plank and Gary Fencik. With his size and speed, Mays will almost be another linebacker in support of the run. The third round brought Navorro Bowman, a linebacker from Penn State who was graded with late first round/early second round talent who fell due to off the field issues.
A late round sleeper looks to be Anthony Dixon, a running back from Mississippi State. Dixon is the power back who can spell Gore and give the 49ers the punishing ground game that Coach Singletary is looking to establish.
Draft Grade: A
Draft Grades: San Diego Chargers
The San Diego Chargers finished the 2009 regular season as a favorite to win the Super Bowl, and two weeks later they were out, falling at home to the New York Jets. The offseason brought a number of changes, most prominent the release of LaDanian Tomlinson, the face of the franchise since 2001. Tomlinson signed with the Jets, who also traded with San Diego to acquire Antonio Cromartie. Jamal Williams leaves a big hole in the middle of the defense, signing as a free agent with Denver.
San Diego made a bold move in the 2010 NFL Draft by trading up from #28 to #12 and selecting Ryan Mathews, a running back from Fresno State. Mathews will be expected to carry the ball and provide the power running to an offense that has one of the best passing attacks in the NFL.
Defense was the focus for the rest of the draft. Donald Butler and Darrell Stuckey were selected in the second and third rounds. Butler can play inside or outside linebacker. Stuckey gives the Chargers depth in the secondary.
The sleeper pick for the Chargers is Cam Thomas, a nose tackle from North Carolina. The departure of Jamal Williams gives Thomas a chance to start right away at nose tackle. If he can stop up the middle the Chargers defense should be solid again.
Draft Grade: B+
San Diego made a bold move in the 2010 NFL Draft by trading up from #28 to #12 and selecting Ryan Mathews, a running back from Fresno State. Mathews will be expected to carry the ball and provide the power running to an offense that has one of the best passing attacks in the NFL.
Defense was the focus for the rest of the draft. Donald Butler and Darrell Stuckey were selected in the second and third rounds. Butler can play inside or outside linebacker. Stuckey gives the Chargers depth in the secondary.
The sleeper pick for the Chargers is Cam Thomas, a nose tackle from North Carolina. The departure of Jamal Williams gives Thomas a chance to start right away at nose tackle. If he can stop up the middle the Chargers defense should be solid again.
Draft Grade: B+
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)